Abstract: Neurocutaneous Syndrome (NCS) is a dental toxicity disorder causing various neurological and dermatological symptoms that are often confused by the lay patient as parasitological infections. The cases of 24 randomly selected patients determined to be NCS cases at Parasitology Center, Inc. (PCI) by OMA are presented. Previously reported and additional toxic sealants are reported. The dermatological and neurological symptoms characteristic of NCS were common to all 24 cases. Incubation period varied between a few hours and 19 years. Inaccurate interpretation of NCS symptoms by health care professionals is discussed. Faulty diagnosis undermines the patients physical and mental health and further traumatizes their quality of life especially when they are diagnosed with mental disorders and forced to submit to psychological treatment against their will. Medical professionals need to become more aware of NCS symptoms to properly tend to their patients well being.
Introduction
Neurocutaneous Syndrome (NCS), a newly discovered dental toxicity syndrome (Amin, 2001) is characterized by neurological and dermatological disorders as well as systemic and related dysfunctions. Patients experience, among other symptoms, pin-prick movement sensations and itchy cutaneous lesions that may invite various opportunistic infections. Components of the calcium hydroxide sealants Dycal, Life, and Sealapex, among others, have been identified as the source of the observed symptoms. The toxicity of sealants, compounding factors and case histories were discussed and management protocols practiced at Parasitology Center, Inc. (PCI) were proposed by Amin (2003, 2004).
Lay NCS patients often confuse the movement sensations, itchy skin and related symptoms with parasitic infections and seek medical help under this assumption. Invariably, they are diagnosed with and treated for other etiologies often including arthropod infestation and/ or mental conditions such as psychosis. Patients are genuine clinical cases that should not be further compromised by inaccurate diagnosis, wrongly medicated or subjected to psychological treatment in mental health care facilities. On occasions, I spend time helping NCS patients out of mental facilities. The institutionalization of some patients seriously compromise their state of mental and physical health, self confidence, and their ability to make sound decisions.
This paper address the various aspects of diagnosis of NCS patients by MDs, dermatologists and other health care professionals as well as the symptoms and outcome of 24 NCS patients.
Materials and Methods
Files of 24 patients were randomly selected from among those examined at PCI and determined by OMA as NCS cases. Information on patients' dental history, symptoms, interpretation of NCS symptoms by health care professionals, diagnosis at PCI by OMA and outcome were compiled from our files and summarized in Table 1. All patients were personally interviewed and information provided was substantiated with documents, dental histories and personal observations. Dermatological symptoms were invariably documented by photos taken by OMA. Patients pursuing dental rehabilitation were initially referred to a holistic dentist, started off on a prescribed regimen of vitamins and supplements, required to take a biocompatibility blood test for sensitivity to dental material and, more recently, underwent laser and lymph drainage therapy at PCI.
Results and Discussion
Patients
References
Amin, O. M. 2001. Neuro-cutaneous Syndrome (NCS); a new disorder. Explore, 10: 55-56.
Amin, O.M. 2003. On the diagnosis and management of neurocutaneous syndrome
(NCS), a toxicity disorder from dental sealants. Explore, 12: 21-25.
Amin, O.M. 2004. Dental sealant toxicity: Neurocutaneous Syndrome (NCS), a
dermatological and neurological disorder. The Communicator, Holistic Dental
Association Journal, 2004: 1-15.
Pseudo-diagnosis by Medical Professionals
* Diagnosis given by other medical professionals re NCS symptoms.
1
DB: white female from California born on 4-9-65
10 amalgam
restorations in 1982
and 1983 using
Life.
NCS symptoms first noted
in 2001/2002. Sores, swelling,
diffuse rash, black specks
(fungal spores), pin prick and
subcutaneous crawling
sensations.
Anxiety disorder
Sores dismissed
as not clinically
genuine. Patient
declared normal.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 12-12-02.
Treatment in progress.
Fig. 6 (Amin, 2003,
2004).
2
JB: white
female from
Arizona, born
on 6-19-74
10 fillings: 6 amalgam
(1978-88), 2 caulk
(zinc oxide & eugenol,
1988) sealant, 2 silux
composite (1990)
Open sores, rashes, excretions,
pin prick & crawling sensations,
high fever, joint pain
Hypertension,
referred to Pulmonary.
Staphylococcus (11-11-03)
Impetigo (9-2-03),
sebaceous cysts (11-14-03,
blood pressure medication,
Diagnosed with NCS
on 11-24-03. Follow
up information not
available.
3
ME: white
female from
Sweden, born
on 5-26-51
Dycal sealants in 20
teeth in 1985; allergic
to sulfa. Dycal removed
in 1991, 92 and initially
replaced with Harvard
cement. Initial healing
period was painful.
Typical sulfa toxicity symptoms,
oozing diffuse skin and nasal
sores, memory loss, kidney
pain, sensitivity to light and
electricity, pin prick and crawling
sensations, itching, breathing
difficulties. Photosensitivity
produced blotchy skin with
severe burning sensations in
face, throat and chest. Fatigue.
Polyneuropathy, atopic
dermatitis. Toxic
ulcerative dermatitis.
Diagnosed in Sweden
with Dycal related
syndrome. Severe
musculo skeletal
pain and bowel
disturbances during
initial stages of
dental rehabilitation.
Complete recovery
since 1992 after 1 year
of rehabilitation. Case
no. 1 in Amin (2003)
4
BG: white
male from
New Mexico,
born in 1962
Allergic to bonding
sealant (Heraeus
Albabond ET) in 3 of 4
crowns removed (much
amalgam underneath).
One filling and 2 overlays
redone on 4-24-03.
Skin sores and lesions. Burning
eyes, recurrent respiratory
infections, memory loss, blurred
vision, allergies.
Not taken seriously
Told lesions were self
inflicted, depression.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 4-17-04. Follow
up information not
available.
5
LG: white
female from
California,
born in 1957
Dycal in tooth #18 on
9-18-1998. Allergic to
sulfa. Removed Dycal
in April, 2002 and
replaced with Starflow
and Aria.
Symptoms started same day.
Lesions, open sores, grayish
secretions with springtails and
fibers, pin prick, movement
sensations, high blood pressure,
fatigue, heart palpitations, valve
prolapse, fatigue, swelling,
weight loss.
Crazy, self inflicted
wounds, stress,
anxiety, almost
admitted to insane
asylum. Scabies
(no mites demonstrated).
Diagnosed with NCS
in Jan. 2002. All
symptoms resolved
by May, 2002. Case
no. 3 in Amin (2003,
2004).
6
AH: white
American
female born
on 1-21-1932
Used Life and
Sealapex; date
undetermined.
Inflammation, rashes, movement
sensations, Used Sulfa derm
once on face; discontinued
because of irritation.
Dermatitis (1-23-00),
treated with
Clobetasol. Scabies
(10-9-01, no mites
demonstrated),
treated with
Mebendazole.
Diagnosed with NCS.
Follow up information
not available.
7
EJ: white
female from
Norway, born
on 5-22-71
7 fillings using Dycal & Life
(ethyltoluene sulfonamide, zinc
oxide) with Clearfil SE primer
(2-hydroxyethyl-methacrylate,
dimethacrylates) bond
in 1979 (at age 7). Root
canal in 1 tooth using
Procosol in 1995. Highly
reactive to Dycal & Life
(bio-compatibility test).
NCS symptoms first observed in
1989. Dental decay, sores, pin
prick, crawling sensations, heart
palpitations, memory loss,
breathing and intestinal
disturbances, swelling, fatigue,
insomnia, electro-magnetic
sensitivity, night fevers/ sweats,
trauma, gray gum tissue and
tongue.
Delusionary parasitosis,
cancer, unspecific
dermatitis, scabies
(no skin samples taken
and no mites or
parasites recovered).
Treated with Dalacin,
Tetracycline Arco,
Differin; no improvement.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 4-23-04.Completed
dental rehabilitation
within 1 month.
Supplements, laser
treatment and
lymph drainage
continue. Neurological symptoms resolved in 8 months.
8
JK: white
female from
Wisconsin,
born in 1950
4 root canals using
Gutta Percha and
Sultan in 1996-98.
Itchy sores, crawling sensations,
Allergy to metals.
Sores dismissed
as self-inflicted.
Sensations declared
imaginary.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 3-16-2004.
Dental rehabilitation
in progress.
9
SK: white
female from
California,
born 9-17-56
Porcelain veneers
cemented with zinc
oxide and Durelon in
the 1990's.
Pain, inflammation, widely
diffused lesions, itching, shaking,
joint pain, coated tongue, fungal
infections, recurrent reaction to
sulfa drugs.
Superficial and
deep perivascular
dermatitis. Treated
with Augmentin,
Vicodin, Tinidazole,
cod liver oil.
Diagnosed with NCS
in December, 2002.
(Fig. 5 in Amin, 2003,
2004). Follow up
information not
available.
10
GK: white
female from
Alaska, born
in 1954.
5 resin fillings (silicate
based methyl
methacrylate, 9-13-00);
2 gold crowns (biogold,
8-2001); 2 root canals
(Gutta Percha, 2002);
2 porcelain crowns
(9-2002).
Rash all over body, crawling
sensations, breathing difficulties,
angina, pain. Sensitivity to
sulfa.
Pericarditis, meningitis,
encephalitis. Treated
with Biotics ADP and
heavy metal protocol.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 4-15-03. Removed
affected teeth same
month. Dermatological,
neurological & other
systemic problems
resolved within a few
weeks.
11
JM: white
female from
Arizona/
Colorado
on 4-17-65
17 fillings; 16 with Dycal.
Dycal removed in 2001.
Followed by initial
episodes of sickness,
sweats & vomiting.
First NCS symptoms noted in
1991. Rash, ulcerations,
crawling and pin prick
sensations, vomiting, joint and
dental pain, insomnia, swelling,
skin peeling & tracks, elevated
veins, red hot face and chest,
body tremors, hair loss, night
fevers, coughing, heavily
medicated.
Psychotic; delusional
parasitosis; not taken
seriously as a genuine
clinical case by
medical professionals
or family/ friends.
Diagnosed with NCS
in Sept., 2000.
Complete resolution
of all symptoms by
mid 2002. Case no. 2
in Amin (2003, 2004).
12
KM: white
female from
Arizona born
in 1966.
Life in 3 teeth (1987,
91, 93).
Skin sores, crawling & pin prick
sensations, scalp irritation,
changes in hair quality,
respiratory difficulties.
Walking pneumonia,
environmentally induced
asthma (11-2002).
Treated with Doxipin,
Capex shampoo,
Stromectal.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 12-16-02. Follow
up information not
available. Figures 1, 2
(Amin, 2003, 2004).
13
KM: white
female from
California,
born in 1964
3 fillings using Dycal: 2
in 1982 & 1 in 2002.
Dycal removed on 12-2002.
Crawling sensations in upper
quadrant started in 1997.
Cutaneous sores & rashes
started in spring 2002 preceeded
by extensive treatment with
topical sulfa products for possible
"mite infestation." Hot-red skin.
Scabies (never
demonstrated). Treated
with Elimite, Ivermectin
and herbs.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 11-19-02.
Progressive resolution
of all symptoms
following removal of
Dycal.
14
MM: white
female from
California, born
on 9-2-50
Fynal in 6 teeth in 1981
and in 1 tooth in 1986.
Life in 2 teeth in 1985 &
1988 (root canal, impacted
teeth, metal rods, crowns).
Highly reactive to Life and
Dycal (compatability test).
Large mucoid lesions on face,
pain, black specks (fungal
spores), excretions, intense
itching, ringing in ears, crawling
sensations, poor circulation,
compromised immunity.
Psychosis (2-1999);
hyperkeratosis,
hemachromatosis
mercury poisoning,
over use of anti-
biotics (1998).
Diagnosed with NCS
in 1999. Finally
undertook total dental
rehabilitation in May
and June, 2004. Fig.
4 (Amin, 2003, 2004).
15
TR: white
female from
Nevada, born
on 10-8-64.
5 molars using Dycal;
records not available.
Removed all molars in
September 2003.
Diffuse skin eruptions throughout
entire body, severe itching,
crawling sensations, fatigue.
Delusional parasitosis,
dermatitis.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 2-13-2003. All NCS
symptoms resolved
shortly after removal
of toxic molars.
16
TS: white
female from
Arizona, born
in 1969.
5 teeth sealed: 3 with IRM
and 2 with Sultan U/P; 14
teeth with Gluma One
Bond and Scotch Bond
(containing hydroxyethyl
methacrylate)(1995-96).
Severe open lesions on arms
and face, crawling sensations,
pain, night sweats, chills, fever,
nausea, headaches, stomach-
aches.
Unspecific dermatitis.
Diagnosed with NCS
3-4-2003. Follow up
information not
available.
17
PS: white
female from
Arizona, born
on 2-28-53
9 teeth with Dycal: 3 in
1977, 2 in 82, 1 in 83,
1 in 85, 2 in 87.
Durelon and Fugi cement
also used.
Diffuse rashes, fibers, crawling
sensations, sleep disorders, GI
problems.
Psychosis, anxiety
disorder (4-18-2000),
eryhtroporetic
protoporphyria (March
98), neurodermatitis.
Diagnosed with NCS
in Dec., 2002.
Rehabilitation in
progress.
18
CS: white
female from
Arizona, born
on 4-19-35
5 teeth with Dycal;
records not available.
Skin lesions, itching, biting
sensations, fibers, superimposed
fungal infection.
Delusional parasitosis,
Dermatitis, blood
bacteria (1-27-02),
seborrheic keratosis
(2-10-03).
Diagnosed with NCS
on 2-10-03. Extracted
2 compromised teeth
in late 2003 and
3 remaining teeth on
5-21-04. Some
symptoms relieved.
Recovery in progress.
19
KS: white
female from
Arizona,
born ca. 1965
cemented veneer in
#24. Tooth extracted in
early Nov., 2002.
First noted NCS symptoms in
3-2002. Sore & facial lesions,
crawling and pin-prick
sensations.
Dismissed with mental
disorders and psychosis,
under psychiatric care
in mental facility for
weeks until helped out
by author.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 10-23-02. Full
recovery by end of
Nov., 2002.
20
JT: white
male from
California,
born in 1951.
4 fillings in 1984-87 with
crowns, bridge. Apicoectamy
in 1 molar, 1 extraction, 2
fillings in 1988. 4 teeth
extracted in 1991, 94, 95,
98 because of extreme
pain. 1 tooth filled with
Tetric (Mono &
DiMethacrylates &
Titanium dioxide) in 1998.
First noted NCS symptoms in
2003. Lesions, hyper-sensitivity,
painful sores, itching, pin prick,
crawling & burning sensations,
brain fog, memory loss, inflamed
gums, dental decay & abcesses,
breathing disturbances,
sinus infections, depression.
Scabies & lice
(2003; mites not
demonstrated).
Depression; sleeping
aids, e.g.,
Trazodone.
on 4-20-04. Dental
rehabilitation in
progress.
21
KT: white
female from
Illinois
Presumptive Dycal
treatment; dental records
not available.
First NCS symptoms noted in
2003. Skin pistules, scabs,
biting pain, itching, crawling
sensations, swelling, black
specks (fungal spores). Allergic
to sulfa.
Scabies (8-14-03;
mites not demonstrated),
treated with Pyrmythrin,
Elimite,Prednisone.
Dermal candidiasis,
angular chelitis (6-10-99).
Diagnosed with NCS
on 8-19-03. Follow
up information not
available.
22
JT: white
female from
Georgia
Fynal in 8 teeth, Eugenol
used as cement in 1992.
Extensive skin lesions, crawling
sensations, memory problems,
insomnia, dizziness, fatigue,
headaches, joint pain, fibers &
filaments.
Delusional parasitosis
& fibromyalgia.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 3-25-03. Follow
up information not
available.
23
TV: white
female from
Arizona, born
on 8-4-61
Root canal on 4-9-02;
Dycal used but not
documented. Decay
and leakage.
Whitish/ gray skin excretions,
sores, rash, itching, burning
sensation, gastric discomfort,
cramps, diarrhea.
Body lice (1-17-03;
not demonstrated).
Treated with Elimite.
Bacterial vaginosis,
parasitosis (8-14-02).
Diagnosed with NCS
on 3-26-03. Follow
up information not
available.
24
CW: white
female from
Arkansas
Two teeth compromised
with Dycal; date not
available.
First NCS symptoms noted
in 2002. Diffuse rash, itching,
superimposed fungal infections.
Delusionary parasitosis,
pruritis (3-18-03),
chronic dermatitis,
superficial lymphocytic
dermatitis with
eosinophils.
Diagnosed with NCS
on 4-24-03. The 2
compromised teeth
were rehabilitated.
Full recovery shortly
afterwards.
The NCS patient population clearly includes many more females than males. The reported random sample of 24 patients included two 42 and 53 years old males (mean 47) and 22 33-79 years old females (mean 45). Twenty-two patients were from the United States and two from Europe, Norway & Sweden. The predominance of females among NCS cases is not fully understood in cases of toxicity disorders. Whether susceptibility to toxins such as sulfa may be differentially mediated by hormones or not is unknown.
Dental History
The sealants incriminated in the 24 NCS cases studied (Table 1) included the zinc oxide/ ethyltoluene sulfonamide sealants Dycal, Life and Sealapex, among others, previously reported to be toxic (Amin, 2003, 2004). Other dental material including zinc oxide, e.g., Caulk and Gutta Percha that were not reported by Amin (2003, 2004) were also involved in new NCS cases reported herein e.g., cases no. 2, 8 and 10. Most cases seen by me within the last two years were compromised by dental work using toxic material as early as 1978 (case no. 2) while others as recent as 2002 (case nos. 10, 19) (Table 1).
Symptoms
The most common dermatological and neurological symptoms of NCS were observed in all 24 patients. Some of these patients had well documented sulfa sensitivity. Other systemic difficulties, e.g., respiratory, intestinal were also noted (Table 1). The time between the original dental procedure and first appearance of symptoms (incubation period) varied between a few hours (case no. 5) and 19 years (cases nos. 1 & 20) (Table 1). We have other records of incubation periods of up to 32 years. Amin (2004) indicated that “the toxicity of ethyltoluene sulfonamide is determined by the concentration of this compound in the sealant used, the amount of sealant used and number of teeth involved” and that “the patient's reaction will depend on the degree of sensitivity to the compounds. These variables determine the time after which the patient will begin to experience symptoms.”
Diagnosis Given
Diagnosis given by health care professionals usually involved arthropods (that are never recovered), and unspecific dermatitis for which patients were medicated but showed no improvement. What is most disturbing is diagnosing patients with various mental disorders, e.g., psychosis, anxiety disorder, delusional parasitosis or the charging that the dermatological symptoms were self inflicted. Thirteen patients (54%) were given diagnosis of mental disorders (Table 1). The ensuing trauma has driven a few of my patients to the edge, contemplating suicide. Medical professionals do need to have a better understanding of NCS as a genuine clinical syndrome and deal with their patients from that perspective.
Diagnosis at PCI
Most of the reported patients were diagnosed with NCS at PCI by OMA within the last two years. Those that followed up with our treatment recommendations (Amin, 2004) had invariably recovered (cases nos. 5, 10, 12, 13, 15, 19, 24). Recovery of a few other patients is partial or underway; more time is needed. Depending on the toxicity variable mentioned above (see symptoms), recovery can take anywhere between a few weeks and up to one year. Fully recovered patients, however, may retain some sensitivities to mold or humid un-aerated places. Early stages of healing can become quite painful, e.g., case no. 3 (Table 1).